The average price for a single family house in Caledonia WI is $560,056. 20 listings have accepted offers out of 80 listed (25%). The average square footage is 2,227 sqft. The average price per square foot is $280.00/sqft across all active homes for sale in Caledonia.
10-24-2026 - Sort & Search Caledonia listings by price, sqft, price per sqft and more. Updated daily.
| View | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7207 County Highway V - | $2.1M | 2 | 1 baths | 64.09 | $3,315 | 1,140 | $1,855 | View |
| 704 Waters Edge Rd accepted offer | $1.9M | 4 | 5 baths | 1.55 | $23,722 | 7,103 | $282 | View |
| 5623 River Hills Rd | $880k | 4 | 6 baths | 3.37 | $12,975 | 4,528 | $194 | View |
| 332 4 Mile Rd | $850k | 2 | 2 baths | 9.79 | $2,374 | 1,255 | $677 | View |
| 3417 Long Furrow Rd | $848k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.64 | $0 | 2,282 | $372 | View |
| 12918 Bell Rd | $820k | 3 | 4 baths | 5.00 | $10,939 | 3,407 | $241 | View |
| 6735 Blue River Way accepted offer | $799k | 5 | 4 baths | 0.47 | $10,317 | 3,800 | $211 | View |
| 5780 Stefanie Way | $799k | 5 | 4 baths | 2.29 | $11,737 | 3,816 | $210 | View |
| 5765 Stefanie Way | $799k | 5 | 3 baths | 1.00 | $9,381 | 4,048 | $198 | View |
| 7305 Farm Meadow Rd | $798k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.43 | $0 | 2,425 | $329 | View |
| 3359 Stone Meadow Ct | $789k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.32 | $2,025 | 2,502 | $316 | View |
| 7329 Farm Meadow Rd | $762k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.35 | $0 | 2,226 | $343 | View |
| 7353 Farm Meadow Rd | $759k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.33 | $0 | 2,272 | $334 | View |
| 3246 Blue Star Cir | $750k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.34 | $5,492 | 2,405 | $312 | View |
| 1228 5 Mile Rd accepted offer | $675k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.45 | $9,337 | 3,558 | $190 | View |
| 3240 Blue Star Cir | $674k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.23 | $989 | 1,806 | $374 | View |
| 3639 Perennial Pkwy | $674k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.23 | $2,025 | 2,499 | $270 | View |
| 5950 Lillie Cir | $649k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.38 | $0 | 2,931 | $222 | View |
| 3232 Bergamot Dr | $639k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.25 | $1,027 | 1,846 | $347 | View |
| 12629 Blue Stem Trl accepted offer | $629k | 4 | 2 baths | 1.20 | $8,490 | 2,245 | $281 | View |
| 6038 Sean Ct | $624k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.46 | $0 | 2,172 | $288 | View |
| 5344 Willowview Rd | $619k | 5 | 5 baths | 0.25 | $5,353 | 2,906 | $213 | View |
| 3744 Morris St | $617k | 5 | 3 baths | 0.21 | $6,454 | 3,050 | $203 | View |
| 4526 Sina Ln | $614k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.29 | $493 | 1,939 | $317 | View |
| 3330 Taurus Dr | $599k | 3 | 4 baths | 0.88 | $7,600 | 3,126 | $192 | View |
| 4815 Crystal Spg | $599k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.30 | $813 | 2,016 | $298 | View |
| 3755 Perennial Pkwy | $585k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.19 | $110 | 2,499 | $234 | View |
| 620 5 Mile Rd | $579k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.24 | $0 | 2,056 | $282 | View |
| 5730 Eagle Point Dr | $559k | 4 | 5 baths | 0.32 | $8,597 | 3,500 | $160 | View |
| 7326 Forty Acre Rd | $549k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.53 | $8,359 | 3,032 | $181 | View |
| 3700 Bishops Cap Dr | $547k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.18 | $44 | 2,211 | $248 | View |
| 5974 Lillie Cir | $544k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.51 | $0 | 1,879 | $290 | View |
| 1308 5 Mile Rd | $529k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.46 | $8,402 | 2,228 | $237 | View |
| 3661 Perennial Pkwy | $524k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.20 | $46 | 2,072 | $253 | View |
| 5714 Richwood Ln | $524k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.26 | $6,743 | 1,801 | $291 | View |
| 802 5 Mile Rd | $519k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.29 | $0 | 1,482 | $351 | View |
| 5003 Bluebird Ln accepted offer | $515k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.32 | $6,901 | 3,059 | $168 | View |
| 710 5 Mile Rd | $509k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.25 | $0 | 1,577 | $323 | View |
| 704 5 Mile Rd | $509k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.27 | $2,026 | 1,503 | $339 | View |
| 4522 LaSalle St | $509k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.20 | $416 | 1,796 | $284 | View |
| 6025 Maxwell Ct | $504k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.36 | $0 | 1,660 | $304 | View |
| 3406 State Highway 38 - | $499k | 4 | 3 baths | 1.68 | $5,024 | 2,755 | $181 | View |
| 3554 Cranberry Ln | $499k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.42 | $8,491 | 2,748 | $182 | View |
| 9140 Morgan Ct | $499k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.36 | $6,235 | 2,736 | $182 | View |
| 3609 Morris St | $488k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.17 | $831 | 1,690 | $289 | View |
| 3708 Bishops Cap Dr | $484k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.20 | $44 | 1,766 | $275 | View |
| 2733 4 1/2 Mile Rd | $475k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.45 | $6,312 | 2,073 | $229 | View |
| 929 5 Mile Rd | $474k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.29 | $2,291 | 1,510 | $315 | View |
| 2607 5 Mile Rd | $470k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.33 | $6,194 | 1,843 | $255 | View |
| 3633 Morris St accepted offer | $465k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.20 | $6,349 | 1,796 | $259 | View |
| 9120 Prairie Crossing Dr accepted offer | $450k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.18 | $6,988 | 1,650 | $273 | View |
| 5236 Willowview Rd accepted offer | $440k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.25 | $6,156 | 2,596 | $169 | View |
| 2121 September Dr accepted offer | $429k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.26 | $7,924 | 2,396 | $179 | View |
| 9018 Morgan Ct | $429k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.33 | $5,798 | 2,297 | $187 | View |
| 1106 Hialeah Dr | $429k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.26 | $6,504 | 2,948 | $146 | View |
| 12220 Eau Galle Rd accepted offer | $424k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.53 | $2,826 | 1,864 | $228 | View |
| 5937 4 Mile Rd | $424k | 2 | 2 baths | 1.67 | $6,200 | 1,992 | $213 | View |
| 2120 Autumn Dr | $415k | 3 | 4 baths | 0.25 | $5,471 | 1,892 | $219 | View |
| 3011 Bruce Dr | $414k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.51 | $4,943 | 1,840 | $226 | View |
| 5211 Charles St | $399k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.37 | $5,814 | 2,375 | $168 | View |
| 2117 Newberry Ln | $399k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.30 | $5,905 | 2,052 | $195 | View |
| 2728 Stonebridge Dr accepted offer | $399k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.23 | $4,944 | 1,805 | $222 | View |
| 2819 Frontier Dr accepted offer | $399k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.23 | $4,966 | 2,068 | $193 | View |
| 5630 Rachel Gln | $399k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.30 | $5,934 | 2,224 | $179 | View |
| 4844 Erie St accepted offer | $379k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.36 | $5,048 | 2,006 | $189 | View |
| 4514 Tennessee Rd accepted offer | $379k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.44 | $4,691 | 1,618 | $235 | View |
| 3343 State Highway 31 Rd accepted offer | $375k | 5 | 3 baths | 0.44 | $4,007 | 2,403 | $156 | View |
| 7919 Hagemann Rd | $374k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.44 | $4,526 | 1,218 | $308 | View |
| 3020 Navajo Trl | $365k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.18 | $3,403 | 1,700 | $215 | View |
| 545 4 1/2 Mile Rd | $349k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.24 | $4,596 | 1,470 | $238 | View |
| 2622 6 Mile Rd | $344k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.26 | $4,263 | 1,550 | $223 | View |
| 2530 Marigold Ct | $339k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.26 | $3,521 | 1,008 | $337 | View |
| 2035 Dustir Dr accepted offer | $329k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.25 | $4,751 | 1,456 | $227 | View |
| 6901 Middle Rd | $325k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.21 | $4,297 | 1,379 | $236 | View |
| 6023 Princeton Ln accepted offer | $324k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.50 | $5,387 | 2,004 | $162 | View |
| 6727 Lone Elm Dr accepted offer | $289k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.18 | $3,951 | 1,200 | $242 | View |
| 4703 7 Mile Rd accepted offer | $275k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.46 | $4,969 | 1,790 | $154 | View |
| 10435 Caddy Ln | $269k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.23 | $2,768 | 925 | $291 | View |
| 1425 Ellis Ave | $229k | 2 | 1 baths | 0.24 | $3,474 | 1,000 | $230 | View |
| 3316 3 Mile Rd accepted offer | $225k | 2 | 1 baths | 0.44 | $2,881 | 888 | $253 | View |

Get started now on your next transaction in Caledonia WI. | Name: |
| Email: | |
| Phone #: | |
| Message: | |
| | |