The average price for a single family house in New Berlin WI is $508,978. 30 listings have accepted offers out of 41 listed (73%). The average square footage is 2,142 sqft. The average price per square foot is $254.00/sqft across all active homes for sale in New Berlin.
10-24-2026 - Sort & Search New Berlin listings by price, sqft, price per sqft and more. Updated daily.
| View | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2850 S Amor Dr | $1.4M | 4 | 4 baths | 9.00 | $10,179 | 4,434 | $337 | View |
| 13680 W Upland Ridge Ct accepted offer | $1.2M | 4 | 5 baths | 0.52 | $12,823 | 3,981 | $308 | View |
| 4945 S Calhoun Rd accepted offer | $998k | 3 | 3 baths | 6.58 | $7,498 | 2,403 | $415 | View |
| 6045 S Pembrook Ct accepted offer | $699k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.75 | $7,106 | 2,690 | $260 | View |
| 4665 S Delphine Dr accepted offer | $629k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.30 | $5,890 | 2,599 | $242 | View |
| 2003 S Valley Spring Dr accepted offer | $625k | 5 | 4 baths | 0.47 | $6,743 | 4,598 | $136 | View |
| 4134 S Victoria Ct accepted offer | $619k | 3 | 4 baths | 0.29 | $5,468 | 2,521 | $246 | View |
| 13716 W Lilac Ln accepted offer | $595k | 5 | 3 baths | 2.22 | $5,937 | 2,404 | $248 | View |
| 3985 S Stonewood Rd accepted offer | $589k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.26 | $5,880 | 2,282 | $259 | View |
| 14390 W Wilbur Dr | $549k | 5 | 3 baths | 0.29 | $5,165 | 2,352 | $233 | View |
| 3165 S Manor Ct | $544k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.32 | $4,595 | 2,172 | $251 | View |
| 12775 W Scarborough Dr | $509k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.25 | $4,645 | 2,239 | $228 | View |
| 5110 S Woodridge Ln accepted offer | $500k | 4 | 3 baths | 1.03 | $4,929 | 1,935 | $258 | View |
| 4251 S Church Dr accepted offer | $495k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.81 | $4,436 | 1,960 | $253 | View |
| 12655 W Eden Ct | $490k | 4 | 3 baths | 0.20 | $5,746 | 3,242 | $151 | View |
| 14707 W Gatewood Ct accepted offer | $469k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.53 | $4,198 | 2,456 | $191 | View |
| 12731 W Park Ave accepted offer | $464k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.41 | $3,699 | 1,617 | $288 | View |
| 3455 S Russel Rd | $459k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.28 | $5,224 | 2,234 | $205 | View |
| 12585 W Cold Spring Rd accepted offer | $449k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.66 | $4,491 | 1,655 | $272 | View |
| 4495 S Church Dr accepted offer | $449k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.24 | $4,226 | 2,222 | $202 | View |
| 3275 S Thornapple Ln accepted offer | $439k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.65 | $4,164 | 1,590 | $277 | View |
| 13501 W Dakota St accepted offer | $439k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.50 | $4,086 | 1,980 | $222 | View |
| 2100 S Woodshire Dr accepted offer | $434k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.39 | $4,185 | 1,764 | $246 | View |
| 13795 W Graham St accepted offer | $424k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.27 | $4,381 | 2,039 | $208 | View |
| 12600 W Cleveland Ave accepted offer | $424k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.48 | $4,701 | 1,906 | $223 | View |
| 16755 W Hearthside Dr accepted offer | $400k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.49 | $3,828 | 1,570 | $255 | View |
| 3635 S Loretta Ln accepted offer | $399k | 4 | 2 baths | 0.24 | $4,209 | 1,770 | $226 | View |
| 14000 W Wilbur Dr accepted offer | $399k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.29 | $3,990 | 1,641 | $244 | View |
| 1425 S Sunny Crest Dr | $399k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.53 | $4,036 | 1,397 | $286 | View |
| 4995 S Small Rd accepted offer | $399k | 5 | 3 baths | 2.04 | $5,327 | 3,192 | $125 | View |
| 1515 S Sunny Slope Rd | $389k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.43 | $3,592 | 1,700 | $229 | View |
| 16401 W Addison Ave accepted offer | $385k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.32 | $3,677 | 1,838 | $209 | View |
| 2330 S Brookside Pkwy accepted offer | $384k | 3 | 3 baths | 0.38 | $3,926 | 1,392 | $277 | View |
| 1500 S Calhoun Rd accepted offer | $379k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.32 | $3,431 | 1,973 | $193 | View |
| 14215 W Overland Trl accepted offer | $375k | 3 | 2 baths | 1.20 | $4,128 | 1,467 | $256 | View |
| 17230 W Jills Dr | $349k | 4 | 1 baths | 0.52 | $3,773 | 1,362 | $257 | View |
| 3841 S Sunny Ridge Ln accepted offer | $348k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.46 | $3,893 | 1,090 | $319 | View |
| 14800 W Fenway Dr accepted offer | $340k | 3 | 2 baths | 0.27 | $4,408 | 1,722 | $197 | View |
| 12418 W Meadow Ln | $318k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.35 | $2,849 | 1,672 | $191 | View |
| 13501 W Greenfield Ave accepted offer | $299k | 3 | 1 baths | 0.30 | $2,645 | 1,289 | $232 | View |
| 2786 S Moorland Rd | $275k | 5 | 1 baths | 0.85 | $2,772 | 1,457 | $189 | View |

Get started now on your next transaction in New Berlin WI. | Name: |
| Email: | |
| Phone #: | |
| Message: | |
| | |